NAU’s Annual Event Sparks Debate on Foundational Disciplines for a New Civilization
Imagine embarking on a journey to establish a new civilization on a distant moon. What academic discipline would be most crucial for survival? This intriguing question takes center stage at Northern Arizona University’s (NAU) Great Survival Debate, where faculty from diverse fields vie for the title of the most essential discipline.
Since its inception in 2019, the Great Survival Debate has been a hallmark event at NAU, organized by the Department of Theatre and the Department of Philosophy. The event is open to all who wish to participate and observe, celebrating academic diversity in a fun and engaging manner.
“I was directing a production of ‘Mr. Burns, A Post-Electric Play’ and was struck by how few students, staff and faculty go outside of their own departments,” explained Kathleen M. McGeever, chair of the Department of Theatre and the event’s founder. Drawing inspiration from a similar event at the University of Montevallo, McGeever aimed to create a platform that breaks down academic silos. “The goal was to break down silos and expand the views of all that NAU had to offer, but in a fun event that broke down walls good-naturedly.”
Julie Piering, dean of the College of Arts and Letters, assists in organizing this annual event, inviting faculty from various disciplines to join in the intellectual competition. “It becomes really funny really fast,” Piering noted. “It is a great way to showcase what we do and get an in-depth look at what different disciplines have to offer, not only for our students, but also for each other.”
Last year’s champion, Devon Randall from the Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, impressed with an argument highlighting the necessity of fermentation. “It was brilliant,” Piering recalled. “She asked the audience if they liked cheese or beer, arguing that we could not start over our civilization without fermentation.”
Winners are awarded the coveted Axe and a special token related to the year’s scenario. Sanjay Joshi, a history professor, will return to defend his title after missing last year’s event. Joining the debate for the first time is Dana Ernst, chair of the Department of Mathematics and Statistics, eager to advocate for mathematics.
“When I took on the position of chair for the department, I had a mission,” Ernst stated. “I wanted to elevate the importance of mathematicians and how the discipline plays a role in our society. Participating in the Great Survival Debate fits right into my mission.”
This year’s contenders include notable faculty such as Slava Fofanov from the School of Informatics, Computing and Cyber Systems, and Chrissina Burke from Anthropology. Katie Tullmann, chair of the Philosophy Department, will serve as the Devil’s Advocate, challenging the necessity of all disciplines.
McGeever emphasized the inclusivity of the event, stating, “We have been trying to reach every discipline over the years. We hope that everyone can learn something new about the many disciplines we have.”
The decision on the winner is made by a panel of judges, supplemented by audience feedback via an applause-o-meter. During deliberations, attendees can enjoy performances by NAU’s improv troupe or preview upcoming theatrical productions.
“I want everyone in attendance to witness how disciplinarily diverse we are,” Piering stated. “The goal of a university is not just the production of knowledge; it is also, at its core, an essential public good.”
The Great Survival Debate will take place from 6-8 p.m. on Thursday, March 19, at the Clifford E. White Theatre in the Performing and Fine Arts building. The event is free and open to the public.
Read More Here
